Keysight EDUX1052A vs Siglent SDS1104X-U
Head-to-head spec comparison to help you pick the right scope for your bench.
Keysight
$479
Siglent
$419
Spec-by-Spec Comparison
| Spec | Keysight EDUX1052A | Siglent SDS1104X-U |
|---|---|---|
| Bandwidth | 50 MHz | 100 MHz |
| Sample Rate | 1 GSa/s | 1 GSa/s |
| Channels | 2 | 4 |
| Memory Depth | 1 Mpts | 14 Mpts |
| Display Size | 7" | 7" |
| Weight | 3 kg | 3.1 kg |
| Price | $479 | $419 |
| Rating | 5.0/10 | 7.5/10 |
| Protocol Decoder | No | Yes |
| Function Gen | No | No |
| WiFi | No | No |
| Battery | No | No |
| Buy on Amazon · $479 | Buy on Amazon · $419 |
Pros & Cons
Keysight EDUX1052A
Pros
- Keysight brand name carries genuine weight in professional and educational settings
- Excellent build quality and probe quality — designed for daily institutional use
- Good for educational labs with Keysight's courseware integration
- Measurement accuracy you can genuinely trust
Cons
- Only 50MHz and 2 channels for ~$479 — objectively poor value
- No protocol decoding unless you pay for the upgrade option
- Only 1Mpt memory depth — shallower than budget alternatives
- The DS1054Z gives you 4 channels and better specs for $130 less
- No path to growth — the platform has limited upgrade options
Siglent SDS1104X-U
Pros
- 4 channels with 100MHz bandwidth — best of both in Siglent's lineup
- CAN and LIN decoding included — no license fees unlike Rigol
- 14Mpt memory depth for long capture sessions
- Better probe compensation and input specs than older Siglent models
- Siglent's firmware has matured significantly with recent updates
Cons
- ~$419 for a 100MHz, non-touchscreen scope is a stiff ask
- No touchscreen — button navigation only
- 1GSa/s sample rate is adequate but not exceptional
- Rigol DHO924S offers 250MHz and a touchscreen for $30 more
Our Verdicts
Keysight EDUX1052A
The Keysight EDUX1052A exists for one reason: the Keysight brand name, and in some contexts that name justifies the premium. In university labs, professional environments, and anywhere that an audit or institutional requirement specifies Keysight, this scope carries weight that Rigol and Siglent simply don't. The scope itself is well-built and accurate — measurements you can trust without second-guessing. But 50MHz, 2 channels, and 1Mpt memory for $479 is genuinely hard to defend on pure value. A DS1054Z gives you more of everything for $130 less. Buy this only if your employer is paying, your school requires it, or you specifically need Keysight's educational courseware integration — those are real justifications. For pure hobbyist use, you'd be paying 35% more for a brand name.
Siglent SDS1104X-U
The Siglent SDS1104X-U is Siglent's answer to the 4-channel mid-range market, and its CAN/LIN decoding is its killer differentiator. Rigol charges extra for CAN decoding on most models; Siglent includes it free. If you're doing automotive embedded work — car CAN bus debugging, LIN network analysis, anything that touches vehicle electronics — the SDS1104X-U at $419 is the most cost-effective path to proper protocol support. For general hobbyist use without automotive protocol requirements, the DS1054Z at $349 remains better value, and the Rigol DHO924S at $449 offers 250MHz bandwidth and a touchscreen for just $30 more. I'd buy the SDS1104X-U specifically if CAN/LIN decoding is non-negotiable.